The Perfect Match season 4 finale is finally here, and while they weren’t crowned this season’s Perfect Match, fans (aka me) are still wondering: Are Jimmy Presnell and Ally Lewber still together following their time on the show? As you’ve likely noticed, their run wasn’t exactly smooth sailing, what with Ally’s (multiple) make-outs with Dave Hand and Jimmy’s date with Kassy Castillo…and, you know, everything that went down with Hashim Moore.
The real question is, where do Jimmy P. and Ally stand now? Since the show was filmed back in November 2025, a lot has likely changed for these two, and ahead of the finale, it seemed pretty clear that Jimmy and Ally were still pretty friendly (if not a full-on couple!).
For one thing: They’ve been posting up a storm on social media. To quote Jimmy’s fellow Love Is Blind/Perfect Match alum Shayne Jansen’s comment on one of his vids: “Jimmy posting like rent is due tomorrow.”
I mean, they even posted a video in bed together:
But unfortunately, it seems like things didn’t last outside the villa for these two. According to Ally, she and Jimmy continued to date for a bit following the show—with Jimmy even visiting Ally in Los Angeles on a few occasions and FaceTiming her every night—but the distance proved to be too much.
As Ally told Tudum, “He had just moved to Miami, and remember, he’s fresh out of the glow up, so he was having fun. I wasn’t ready to really date either. I feel like it was one of those things where we knew, but we didn’t want to admit it, and we did like each other.”
But then, it seems that Jimmy “started to move weird.” She continued, “Chris was dating Natalie, and now he’s dating Kayla again. Then Jimmy and I were together, then we weren’t together. Now, he’s hanging out with Natalie all the time. It’s a big old confusing thing, but we’re fine.”
Well!
